|
THE
POINT |
Winter Quarter 2007 |
How
to Avoid Plagiarism
Jennifer
Campbell, Richard Colby, and Heather Martin
The University of Denver has defined and
outlined various degrees of plagiarism and its potential consequences
(cf. DUs Faculty Senate approved Guidelines
for Faculty on Student Plagiarism). As a teacher, there are many
ways to address issues of plagiarism in the classroom including in-class
writing, specific and unique assignments, and most importantly, discussions
of writing including research and source attribution in professions
or the discipline. What follows are examples and strategies that might
be helpful in helping students avoid mistakes.
- Provide detailed and unique writing
assignments every term. Too general an assignment or a recycled
assignment creates the potential for a student to accidentally
or purposefully plagiarize. Similarly, recycling the
same assignment year in and year out may allow the opportunity
to provide students with examples of past student work but it can
also prevent them from thinking in unique ways about an assignment.
- Include community-specific or current
events questions in writing prompts. Assignments that ask class,
community, or university specific questions ask students to actively
create and synthesize connections with their own situations and a
topic. Similarly, design writing assignments that include discussion
of current events. Students will have a harder time finding an essay
on a pay site that deals with something that happened last week.
Even in a history class or classical literature class, assignments
can ask how recent events or publications compare to the topic at
hand.
- Assign pre-writing. Plagiarists
often cite poor time management as an excuse for their behavior.
A pre-writing assignment can compel the less organized or less motivated
student to begin the process sooner, consider the assignment more
thoroughly, seek help when needed, and, ultimately, complete the
work on their own. For instance, shortly after giving an assignment,
have students write a paragraph in class telling you what they will
write about and how they plan to start the assignment, and then ask
them occasionally how their research/writing is progressing, possibly
even asking for drafts that are still in the process of being completed.
- Assign in-class writing. In-class
writing, even a paragraph of observation or response to a reading,
can offer insight into the writing abilities of students as well
as their use of sources. These in-class writings can be read quickly
and holistically to gain a sense of whether particular students need
help citing and working with sources, their understanding of the
discourse, and their ability to articulate ideas about topics in
the discipline. Thus, throughout the term, an instructor may write
a comment or two on these paragraphs that help the student better
learn the expectations of writing in the discipline.
- Assign multiple drafts and allow revision. When
time and space allow, ask students to turn in their writing in multiple
stages or drafts. You dont necessarily need to grade or comment
on these attempts just a quick glance and a check mark will ensure
that the writing isnt coming fully-formed from another source.
- Encourage students to thoughtfully reflect
on their writing and writing process. Students who know that
they will be asked to discuss their work in a public forum (like
the classroom) are less likely to submit work that is not their own. For
instance, have students complete a cover sheet for each writing assignment
and then have them discuss it in class. In the cover sheet,
they can explain how they chose their topic, describe their writing
process, explain what they like most about their paper, or what they
would work on if they had more time. Not only will this reflective
process help students think about what worked or didnt work, but
it would be very difficult for students to complete this requirement
if they didnt write the paper themselves.
- Schedule student-teacher conferences. Meeting
with students about a writing assignment will allow them to work
out their ideas with you and can inspire confidence in their abilities
to complete the task, as well as clarify your expectations for the
end product. These meetings will also give you a sense of the direction
that student papers are taking.
- Give specific source requirements. For
example, if a paper must include references from your course textbook
and a journal article/web site, etc., students will be less likely
to find a paper online that uses those sources. This approach can
also encourage students to make use of a variety of resources types.
- Openly discuss definitions of plagiarism
with students. Before assigning writing projects, discuss definitions
of plagiarism. Make it very clear what counts as plagiarism and what
documentation conventions you expect students to follow. Students
might not realize what is inappropriate, especially given the popularity
of sampling and sharing in digital environments. Also, blanket statements
about plagiarism are difficult because certain disciplines, cultures,
and discourse communities may have different definitions of research,
source attribution and citation. Rather than a simple example works
cited or reference page, students might also benefit from discussions
about why sources are given attribution, how and why past research
is built upon and or critiqued, and what role the student has in
entering this conversation.
Front Page
|

 |